Tested News

Why You Should Buy an iPod Classic Before it Goes Away

Last week, Apple revealed it's new line of iPods. Conspicuously absent? The iPod Classic. The high-capacity player is still around, but for how long?

Last week, Steve Jobs took the stage and made an announcement — new iPods were on the way. And not just one or two models either, but updates to the whole line. Available for order in the Apple Store was a new Shuffle, Nano and Touch.
 
Conspicuously absent from that list? The iPod Classic. The venerable clickwheel's lack of inclusion was taken by many as a sign of the apocalypse, prompting worry about the potential absence of a high-capacity player. Disaster was averted, however, when a quick message to Apple PR revealed that the Classic was indeed alive and well, though unchanged in capacity or form.  
 
But for a few brief moments, it seemed as if the age of high-capacity music players had come to an end.

 The Archos 5 Internet Tablet. 160, 250 and 500GB varieties. A dying breed of music players.
The Archos 5 Internet Tablet. 160, 250 and 500GB varieties. A dying breed of music players.
Early MP3 players competed for one thing — storage. Flash players offered no more than a CD's worth of songs when the first iPod was introduced, and even hard-disk offerings could only hold a few thousand at a time. As the years went on, this changed, and capacities of 20, 30 or 60GB weren't unheard of. But then, something changed. Consumers didn't want bulky, hard-drive based models. Flash was smaller, more reliable, and used less power. It also cost a lot more, and held a lot less.
 
Today, it's easy to pick up a cheap, 8GB player, but far more difficult to find a capable model over 100GB in size.  Creative Labs has long since ceased production of any music player over 64GB in size, and moved almost entirely away from hard drive based offerings. Archos only offers larger capacity models in the form of internet tablets and slates — far from an iPod-style dedicated player. Other brand name options are scarce, and even the Zune HD only offers a maximum of 64GB, though we can only hope that beefier capacities are on the way.

  Until wireless connectivity becomes more commonplace, "endless" music libraries like Grooveshark aren&squot;t very viable.
 Until wireless connectivity becomes more commonplace, "endless" music libraries like Grooveshark aren't very viable.
For music collectors, there's little choice. Flash-based devices have become the norm, and capacity hasn't yet reached the size or price advantages of traditional hard drive-based players. And though you could argue a 64GB option on many players is sufficient for modestly sized music collections, once you factor in videos, apps and games, its clear that space will be eaten into quickly. It's obvious this will change in the future, but for now, there's few solutions left for a capable, single-purpose MP3 player or device.

Of course, it may just turn out that the answer isn't even storage at all, but something else entirely. Services like Grooveshark have proved that the cloud could one day power the next-generation of high-capacity players; storage would no longer be an issue, and our libraries only limited by the size of our musical tastes. However , that's wishful thinking — at least for now — and local forms of storage haven't been trumped quite yet. 

Until then, what's a hapless music lover to do? Stock up on iPod Classics, or similarly sized players — and do it now. If there's one thing Apple's exclusion of the Classic from last week's press conference reveals, it's that the day's of high-capacity music players are numbered. Some people just want to take all their music with them, and a flash-based Touch just wont cut it. 
 
Lead image via flickr user Jonathan Urch.
Lasheon Sept. 7, 2010 at 2:40 a.m.

The only real issue I have with the Classic is the inevitable death of the hard drive - I wake up in cold sweats with nightmares of old hard drives through the ages clicking away!
 
I think a 64gb flash-based device is more than enough as stated in the article and while videos, apps etc do infringe on the storage significantly, if I was dedicated to a one-device for all my music needs I would simply avoid the app/video options and sync music alone. 
 
That said though I have sold myself into the cloud - as a Spotify subscriber I am no more than a click away from any song I could care for, save for precious few artists whom I dedicate my device's local memory to. I can sync up albums for offline play in the morning on a whim, or browse around latest releases on the move. I can share playlists with friends and sync their recommendations for my morning commute, then discuss the music with them upon arrival at Uni, work, etc.
 
It's liberating, legal, and it's only going to get better over time.  
 
...click...click...click.
Bowlbyon Sept. 7, 2010 at 2:49 a.m.
Wireless networks or 3G connections would have to become ubiquitous for streaming services to work, and the regular data plan caps would have to be extended significantly. 
 
I'd like to think that high-capacity players have a place in the future, but it all depends on what Apple's sale sheet looks like. I think the Classic will be ditched at some point, simply because they want to get everyone on iOS, using the software and dowloading apps. I just wish there were a Flash-based player that had high capacity and cost a reasonable amount of money. :(
ebritton Sept. 7, 2010 at 2:57 a.m.
My issue is you essentially pay the same amount for a 160GB classic as you do for an 8GB touch. It then costs £150 more to get the 64 GB touch, I could basically buy two classics for that much. As all I want is music, and the occasional mass storage device, the ipod classic serves it's purpose and serves it well and I will be sad to see it go.
thabigredon Sept. 7, 2010 at 3:19 a.m.
iPod is what made the apple peripheral market what it is today, they will never discontinue that brand.
Theresonlyoneon Sept. 7, 2010 at 3:32 a.m.
It won't go away as long as it continues to make money.
LukeA256on Sept. 7, 2010 at 3:38 a.m.
I bought a 160 GB iPod Classic when they were still around. I'm glad I did. I wont upgrade till it breaks, by then flash will be high enough capacity I hope. Going by the life of my old hard drive based iPod though they will. I still have a fully working first gen iPod. Even if the battery only lasts 5 minutes now days :)
ptyson Sept. 7, 2010 at 5:17 a.m.
The original wheel design has a certain cool retro identity to it, which all this touch stuff will lose. My favorite design is still the 3rd Gen. nano, but noticed how Steve Jobs avoided commenting on it during the press conference when he was going through the evolution diagram. Apple is losing it's cool.
lane moderator on Sept. 7, 2010 at 5:26 a.m.
Don't forget that the Zune Classic is still alive and well, too.
 
I'll never understand why someone wouldn't want a high-capacity music player. Stick all your tunes on it and never worry about what you have or haven't synced. It's the way the world should be.
Forteon Sept. 7, 2010 at 5:39 a.m.
@lane: Because not all of us have that much music.  I use my nano exclusively for podcasts.  I have no desire to put music on it.
lane moderator on Sept. 7, 2010 at 6:33 a.m.
@Forte: 
 
I don't understand. How do you listen to your Bruce Springsteen discography?
filreedon Sept. 7, 2010 at 6:40 a.m.
Is it still the case that the classic has the better sound quality? I believe it was better than the iPhone/touch 3g(s) but not sure about the iphone4. 
The impression I get from talking to (admittedly not a large group of) iphone users is that they're more interested in features than sound quality!
Skipon Sept. 7, 2010 at 6:45 a.m.

If you have a decent number of albums and save everything as lossless files you can fill a flash player pretty quickly.  I rarely use my 5th Gen iPod, but I do use it for parties or events where I need several hours of music and need to not worry about tending it.  It's also great for long road trips.
Scotty_Gunon Sept. 7, 2010 at 7:01 a.m.

I can appreciate the desire for a high capacity music player.  However, unless you are using it for A LOT of video playback, an 8GB or smaller player suits the "average" consumer just fine.  My 4GB nano holds over 24 hours of music.  I actively curate my music collection.  I think I've got around 20GB of music and I still haven't found 4GB worth of songs where I won't want to skip every other one.
eXS10son Sept. 7, 2010 at 8:01 a.m.
@lane:

WHERE?! I've been looking for a feasible deal on a Zune classic for what seems like forever now!

Let's get one thing straight, a Zune is nothing more than the poor man's iPod, but I have not seen a Zune classic for sale at an actual retailer, or even online for that matter, in at least a year.

BigJames79on Sept. 7, 2010 at 8:14 a.m.

The only high capacity devices they want us to have are computers. When we're mobile, they want us to be on the cloud. In the end, I'm gonna get a classic before it goes away. I was hoping that there would be a 320gb or 500gb by now, but oh well. I'll take the 160gb slim and keep it moving... 

lane moderator on Sept. 7, 2010 at 8:20 a.m.
@exs10s: 
 
Y'know, that's a good question. I've been saying that Zunes are still available whenever this topic comes up because they were never EoL'd, but I can't actually find one to buy. They may be effectively dead after all.
MagusMaleficuson Sept. 7, 2010 at 8:20 a.m.
I'll be happy with my iPod Classic until the day the hard drive fails. I thought about buying another one as a backup, but I'll probably cave in and buy a iPod Touch 64GB (or higher capacity if one exists at that time) when my Classic croaks. I like having my entire collection queued up any time I want it, but I'm ready to get choosy if I have to go the Touch route.
Meteoraon Sept. 7, 2010 at 8:27 a.m.
I like having high capacity MP3s; simply because I'm too lazy to select which music I want to listen to on my iPod. I just want my entire small library of music on my iPod. =/ 
 
So this is a pity.
Baneon Sept. 7, 2010 at 8:33 a.m.
I have an 80GB Classic that I use solely in the Jeep. It never leaves the glovebox except when I need to sync new tunes. Like you guys said in the podcast, I think the car is the main reason they're still around.
 
My collection is approaching 60GB so maybe I should think about grabbing whatever the largest Classic is these days just to ensure I have as much room to grow as possible.
Ben_Hon Sept. 7, 2010 at 10:43 a.m.
I adore my Classic.  I have the 120 gig model.  I use it every night because I listen to music while I fall asleep.  It's tough enough that I don't have to worry about falling asleep on it and breaking the screen.  I also use it daily in my car.
How To Rip DVDs to Play on Any Device—For Free!

Our ultimate DVD copying guide shows you how to use Handbrake to rip discs for playback on your laptop, Xbox, PS3, iPhone, Zune, netbook, iPad, PSP, iPod, and pretty much anything else

Tested: Apple Mac OS X Lion

The $30 upgrade from Snow Leopard seems like a no-brainer, but that's not the full story. Read the official Tested review.

Apple iPad 2 Review

Our definitive review of the iPad 2.

Tested: Nvidia GeForce GTX 580 Video Card

The green machine comes back swinging.

Apple iPad Wi-Fi Review

Apple's device isn't magical, but it is going to make the tablet a real category--for better or for worse

Video: How To Build the Best $1500 Gaming PC, Step-by-Step

Do you like saving money? What about playing PC games? Have you ever considered building your own PC? We show you exactly what you need to know to build an awesome $1500 gaming PC.

How To Build an Awesome $500 Windows Home Server

We pick the best parts to build a lean media backup and streaming machine.

The Best Android Phone for Your Network (February 2011)

Don't get locked in with the wrong phone.

New High-DPI OS X UI Elements Give Hope for High-Resolution Macs

The iPad 3 is expected to offer a high resolution display; should we expect the same from the MacBook Pro line?

$35 Raspberry Pi Computer Enters Production, Due February 20th

Raspberry Pi's pocket-size Linux computer is inches away from real availability.

Nokia Explains What Makes Its Lumia ClearBlack Screens Unique

Nokia's new displays use polarizers and filters to limit screen reflectance.

AT&T Unreasonably Throttling Users with Unlimited Data Plans

AT&T ignores its responsibility to keep users informed while clearly pushing them towards tiered data plans.

Tested: Google Chrome Beta for Android Ice Cream Sandwich Phones

It's Chrome, shrunken down and blazing-fast on Android.

Windows 8 Metro App Multitasking Will Mimic Mobile Apps

Microsoft details the behavior of suspended and background apps in the WinRT Metro environment.

Logitech Announces a Touch Mouse: Where Have We Seen This Before?

Like the Logitech Wireless Touchpad, the Touch 600M looks an awful lot like an Apple input device with a new skin.

Here's What You Should Expect from Windows 8's Consumer Preview

At the end of February, Windows 8 will be previewed and available for download.

AT&T Unreasonably Throttling Users with Unlimited Data Plans

AT&T ignores its responsibility to keep users informed while clearly pushing them towards tiered data plans.

Windows 8 Start Button May Be Replaced by a Hot Corner and Charms

A recent build of Windows 8 shows the desktop Super Bar minus one Start button.

How Android OEMs Miss the Mark with TV Commercials

A one minute Super Bowl commercial is wasted if the ad doesn't win any converts.

Smart Earphones Know Which Ears They're In, Adjusts Channels Accordingly

A Japanese research project uses proximity sensors to detect which ear earbuds are in and change stereo channels to compensate.

How HTC Squandered Its Android Lead and Had a Mediocre 2011

HTC is experiencing a worrying slide in sales, and here's why.

HDR Photography: Accurate Tone-Mapping or Photo Manipulation?

The use of high dynamic range in photojournalism sparks an argument about digital manipulation.

Tested: Google Chrome Beta for Android Ice Cream Sandwich Phones

It's Chrome, shrunken down and blazing-fast on Android.

Why Apple's A5 Chip in the iPhone 4S is Needed for Siri

Siri only runs on the iPhone 4S thanks to improved, integrated noise cancellation technology integrated into the A5 processor.