What's the Optimal Size and Weight for a Tablet?
As speculation over an Apple tablet began to take over the mobile conversation last year, many companies began developing their own alternatives. While a few have come to market, there are more in the pipeline than you'd expect. We've gotten actual confirmation of the Dell Mini 5 (or the Dell Streak 5), a 5-inch smartphone with a tablet feel. Just today, leaked photos of Dell's entire Streak tablet family surfaced on the web. The lineup includes never-before-seen 7-inch and 10-inch versions. Dell is covering their bases as far as size goes, and that might not be unreasonable. Some manufacturers, like Fusion Garage with the JooJoo, are betting on a larger form factor. But in this newly reinvigorated tablet market, no one knows quite how big these devices should be. We'll take a look at available and upcoming tablets, and help you decide.
 

Dell's leaked documents make it fairly clear that their Android-based tablet line will be called "Streak", but we're still a little unclear how the naming convention will work. The smallest member of that family is the one we have the most information about. The Streak  5 is sort of a hybrid as it's capacitive touchscreen is bigger than a traditional smartphone at 5 inches and 800x480 resolution, but it has 3G phone functionality. We usually think of a 4.3-inch phone like the HTC HD2 or EVO 4G to be at the upper limit of usability, and the Streak 5 might be a bit too big to hold to your ear. But it's unclear if that extra bit of screen real estate will give you a tablet-like experience.

There is a 5MP camera on the back, and a VGA camera on the front. In prototype devices, the Streak 5 seems to be running a skinned version of Android 1.6, but that is likely to change before release. The Dell leaked promotional materials appear to indicate the 5-inch tablet will have content partnerships with Amazon for Kindle and Amazon MP3 access. In most ways, this is being pushed as a tablet. It is expected to ship this summer. A 5-inch tablet might fit in your pocket (unless you wear skinny jeans), but Dell's other offerings won't.
  Dell's Streak Tablets, via Engadget
 Dell's Streak Tablets, via Engadget

The leak of the 7 and 10-inch Dell tablets show a clear intention to compete with the iPad. Even the overall design looks vaguely like the iPad, with the large flat bezel. It makes us wonder if the Streak 5 is in for a redesign to match its big brothers. The Streak 7 should be out late this year, and the Streak 10 will follow in 2011. From the leaked photos, we can definitely tell that the devices have widescreen displays, unlike the iPad. We can only assume these tablets will not have the unexpected phone functionality of the 5-inch version, but they may have 3G data. The larger Streaks are clearly in the not-pocketable category with the iPad.     

The iPad is using a 9.7-inch 1024x768 resolution 4:3 display. The JooJoo ups the ante with a 12-inch 1366x768 widescreen panel. Larger displays can give you a better experience at the expense of portability, but another thing to consider is the screen ratio. The iPad is 4:3 (like an older computer monitor) in order to be comfortable to hold vertically as well as horizontally. Indeed, holding the JooJoo with its sizable 12-inch display in portrait mode looks a bit awkward. Additionally, the JooJoo is basically running netbook internals, and weighs 2.4lbs, which makes using it a workout. That's almost a pound more than the ARM-based iPad at 1.5lbs, which already feels heavy after prolonged use. In the same boat as the JooJoo is the upcoming WePad. The specs are almost identical with an 11.6-inch widescreen display and Atom chipset. The Dell tablets may also suffer from this dilemma, but the slightly smaller size could help.

Archos has a number of tablets on the market as well. Coming in a variety of sizes (like the Dell Streaks), you should be able to find one to fit your needs, or pockets, if you choose to go this route. There is a 5-inch model that runs Android, as well as 7 and 9-inch versions that run a proprietary Linux build. Rumor has it Archos also plans to release a new line of tablets this summer from 3-inches all the way up to 10-inches. These are expected to be ARM-based devices, so weight shouldn't be much of a problem.

The HP Slate was shown off at CES2010 by none other than Steve Balmer, and is often cited as an alternative to the iPad. You're not going to see a lot of difference here from an iPad. The HP Slate will have a 8.9-inch display, but as it's running on an Atom CPU (like the JooJoo and WePad) we're worried it may end up a bit on the heavy side even with the smaller display. But some leaked documents indicate HP has worked hard to keep the weight down, as it's listed at 1.5lbs. That's the same as the iPad.

If you decide to take the plunge and get a tablet, the size is going to be an important factor. If you never want to use something because it's too big, or too small, or too heavy, there's no reason to have it. If you want a bigger screen, it's going to be heavier. Keep an eye on the weight before buying. Even the relatively light iPad can be uncomfortable to use for long periods without resting your arms. If a tablet needs to ride around in your bag all day, a larger tablet like the JooJoo or WePad might be too big and awkward. If you're considering a tablet purchase, how will the size figure into your decision?
13 Comments
fry on April 16, 2010
"Streak??" And I thought "iPad" was funny. Hopefully, that's just a development code name and not the actual market name.
 
"Hey, look! Billy's got a streak in his pants!"
norman on April 16, 2010
@fry: a 10-inch streak in his pants
laxaloot on April 16, 2010
For me, the iPad and HP Slate seem like they will be/are the right size... however... what I am worried about with these new Android tablets is how functional the UI is going to be. Android already looks kind of ugly on a small phone screen. When you say "a skinned version of Android" I hope you mean very very very skinned to the point that it's similar to saying "Android is a skin of Linux."
ryanw on April 16, 2010
@norman:  Before you know it, ScotteVest will be making Streak compatible pants. Everyone will shudder in unison.
sdauz on April 16, 2010
i dont think tablets can be as influential in CE markets until they have a high level of integration with either a pared desktop/laptop or a media server etc.....and its something that comes out of the box rather than a 3rd party app etc
Addfwyn on April 16, 2010
@sdauz: I'm not so sure that 3rd party apps can't be as influential as the stuff that comes out of the box.  Look at most desktop PCs, unless you are buying a Mac for iLife stuff then you're probably mostly using 3rd party utilities.  I don't see why that should be all that different for a portable device.  Most people still use third party apps for media-integration services on their desktop as well.  If anything, it'll allow for nice open-platform standards of communication between desktop and portable version of apps.
itchyeyes on April 17, 2010
I really like the size of my Kindle.  Ideally, if I were to take the plunge on a tablet, I'd like something about that size and weight, where the screen covered the full device, so about 7-8".
ButtonsMcBoomBoom on April 17, 2010
I can't wait for an article to start with "The dell streak marks...."
GozerTC on April 17, 2010
@ButtonsMcBoomBoom:  
 ROFL.  That's so wrong.

@sdauz: 
I agree and disagree with ya here. On the one hand Addfwyn is right that most desktop computer software is "3rd party" and there's no sign of that really changing.  At the same time the iPad SHOULD have a 1st party "desktop integration" system since that's Apple's big deal.  That they're "easy" and "ready to use out of the box."   
 
As a Mac user it was one of the big things I wanted the iPad to do that it doesn't do yet.  It should be like a PADD in that it's a remote interface to a full size computer.  I'm not seeing that yet.  :(     
DarkGamerOO7 on April 18, 2010
"Hello, I'm a Streak"
"And I'm an iPad"
.....
will on April 18, 2010
@itchyeyes: Bezel is important so you have something to hold on to, but I agree with you. Assuming minimal OS chrome, a device about the size of the small Kindle 2 with a big screen is mighty interesting to me.
TheMasterDS on April 18, 2010
I think I'd honestly be most into a tablet that were Courier shaped honestly. It would give it a good portability without sacrificing screen size. 
 
Also this is total crazy talk, but I would love it if it had a tactile screen that was able to alter its texture as to make a virtual keyboard feel right. If it could work like eInk and be suited for the outdoors that be great too.
TeX on April 24, 2010
The lighter and smaller, the better. Ideally, 300 g or so and 5-inch screen or so. Pocketable.
  • Type the words above including the space. Get new words?
Errors will go here
Post Reply
Processing....
Popular News
How To Rip DVDs to Play on Any Device—For Free!

Our ultimate DVD copying guide shows you how to use Handbrake to rip discs for playback on your laptop, Xbox, PS3, iPhone, Zune, netbook, iPad, PSP, iPod, and pretty much anything else

Video: How To Build the Best $1500 Gaming PC, Step-by-Step

Do you like saving money? What about playing PC games? Have you ever considered building your own PC? We show you exactly what you need to know to build an awesome $1500 gaming PC.

How To Build an Awesome $500 Windows Home Server

We pick the best parts to build a lean media backup and streaming machine.

Apple iPad Wi-Fi Review

Apple's device isn't magical, but it is going to make the tablet a real category--for better or for worse

Nexus One vs HTC Desire vs HTC Incredible: What's the Difference?

HTC is releasing more Android phones all the time, but is there a difference?

How To Steal Mac OS's Best Features for Windows

Windows 7's Aero is a fine UI, but there are just a few things it's missing. Here's how to steal some of Mac OS's features.

How To Rip a Blu-Ray Movie with Just One Click

The MakeMKV utility decrypts and rips a Blu-Ray disc with just one click, preserving the original video quality of the source file.

How To Stream All of Your Video Files to iPhone and iPad

Get your DVD rips off your computer and play them on a mobile device, without having to convert them beforehand.

What Kind of Digital Home Upgrades Have You Done?

Ethernet, streaming music, smart power, oh my! What 21st century upgrades have you made to your home?

Why the Obama Administration's Stance on Piracy Sidesteps Complicated Issues

Addressing an audience of workers in the music industry, Commerce Secretary Gary Locke reaffirmed the Obama administration's commitment to cracking down on media piracy on the Internet.

Free Friday - Android Mini-Vinyls! We Love Them So Much!

This week we're giving away an awesome Android Mini figurine. All you need to do to enter is sign up for the site and post a comment in this thread. Yay!

How To Take and Create HDR Photos on Android

Some methods are better than others.

Living with Technology: Two Mice for One Desktop PC

What would drive a man to use two mice for one computer?

Never Give Up: Microsoft May Be Working on One More Zune

Just in time for Apple's new iPod Touch announcement, a rumor is brewing indicating that Microsoft is going to give the Zune another go.

How To Spot Scams and Malware Apps on Android

Some apps are already doing some shady things. Learn how to protect yourself.

Why the All-in-One Multifunction Inkjet Printer is Obsolete

Multifunction printers are big, slow machines that have lots of features, but do none of them well — and they aren't worth your time.

Free Friday - Android Mini-Vinyls! We Love Them So Much!

This week we're giving away an awesome Android Mini figurine. All you need to do to enter is sign up for the site and post a comment in this thread. Yay!

What Kind of Digital Home Upgrades Have You Done?

Ethernet, streaming music, smart power, oh my! What 21st century upgrades have you made to your home?

Never Give Up: Microsoft May Be Working on One More Zune

Just in time for Apple's new iPod Touch announcement, a rumor is brewing indicating that Microsoft is going to give the Zune another go.

Why the Obama Administration's Stance on Piracy Sidesteps Complicated Issues

Addressing an audience of workers in the music industry, Commerce Secretary Gary Locke reaffirmed the Obama administration's commitment to cracking down on media piracy on the Internet.

Living with Technology: Two Mice for One Desktop PC

What would drive a man to use two mice for one computer?

Why the All-in-One Multifunction Inkjet Printer is Obsolete

Multifunction printers are big, slow machines that have lots of features, but do none of them well — and they aren't worth your time.

Why You Should Buy an iPod Classic Before it Goes Away

Last week, Apple revealed it's new line of iPods. Conspicuously absent? The iPod Classic. The high-capacity player is still around, but for how long?

How To Get Great-Sounding Audio for Podcasts and Games

Getting decent audio from your headset or mic isn't hard, and we'll show you a few simple ways to do it.