Tested News

This Is Why People Hate the Phone Company, AT&T

AT&T's triumphant announcement of its long-awaited 3G Microcell calls into sharp relief the fact that we shouldn't have to suffer telecom thievery for much longer

Reading AT&T's announcement that the nationwide rollout of its femtocell product--called the Microcell 3G--is about to begin called into sharp relief the level at which I expect to get screwed by the phone company. About halfway through decoding the PR doublespeak, I had an epiphany. It was if I suddenly saw the words on the page for the very first time. I'm so used to the phone company selling me services I don't need at a price that's unreasonable (bordering on ludicrous) that I'd moved beyond apathy to blind acceptance. Let's break down the femtocell announcement, one paragraph at a time. 

 
AT&T* today announced that AT&T 3G MicroCell plans to begin its national roll out beginning in mid April, with new markets activating in cities across the continental U.S. for the next several months.  AT&T 3G MicroCell is an innovative solution that allows residential customers to route wireless phone calls and data connections (or sessions) across a home broadband connection. This solution is designed to benefit customers who live in homes that have coverage impediments that consistently interrupt wireless spectrum, such as dense wall and roof construction or unfavorable terrain. 

What does all this mean? It's simple. AT&T will finally start rolling out its 3G Microcell in mid-April, with nationwide coverage coming online over the next several months. The Microcell is a device designed solely to plug holes in AT&T's network--it creates a tiny 3G cellular tower for your use in your home that connects to the rest of AT&T's network using  YOUR  broadband connection. Also, the problems that cause your dropped calls (coverage impediments) are mostly your fault, not AT&T's.  

AT&T 3G MicroCell is the only femtocell to support both 3G data and voice services.  Developed in conjunction with Cisco and in a public trial in select markets since September, AT&T 3G MicroCell is available for a one-time cost of $149.99.

$150!!!! Wow, I have to pay $150 because AT&T's shitty network only works in my bathroom? Should a customer who has signed a 2 year contract worth about $100/month have to pay to extend AT&T's network to cover someplace that they spend 12+ hours a day? That's just insane. Also, it seems kind of neat that the Microcell supports 3G data services, but it's a useless feature. Who's going to spend money on one of these that doesn't already have a $50 Wi-Fi access point? Does anyone not have Wi-Fi now?  Are there smartphones without Wi-Fi? If there are, I haven't used one since I ditched Windows Mobile. 

Consumers manage AT&T 3G MicroCell though their online MyWireless account at www.att.com/mywireless. Through this online management, only those phones chosen by the customer may use the MicroCell. Customers may define up to 10 lines to have access and up to four may operate on it simultaneously. Minutes used through the MicroCell affect only the account of the phone making the call – there is no requirement to purchase separate service for the 3G MicroCell.

Even if I'm willing to pay $150 to extend AT&T's shitty 3G network, it will only be accessible to 10 lines, and it will almost certainly be a pain in the ass to add or remove lines. So, when my iPhone toting friends are down to play Rock Band, they too can enjoy getting 5 voice mails the moment they leave the house, each from a call that never rang inside the AT&T black hole that is my home. There is one spot of good news here though, buried at the end of the paragraph: AT&T has decided graciously not to charge me a monthly fee for the privilege of fixing its network. But wait, that sentence right before it, about the minutes? Does that mean I'm still going to be charged for minutes, even when dialing out over my broadband connection instead of AT&T's spendy wireless network? Are they fucking kidding me?

In addition, AT&T will offer a companion rate plan option for MicroCell customers – especially customers on Family Talk plans -- who want to supplement their existing voice plans.  For $19.99 a month, individual or Family Talk customers can make unlimited calls through a 3G MicroCell, without using minutes in their monthly wireless voice plan.

Oh I get it now. This is a revenue opportunity. You know, for AT&T. For $150 down, I can use my broadband connection to extend AT&T's shitty network, but if I don't want those calls to eat my minutes I have to pay ANOTHER $20 a month? This is extortion.  

Consumers who select 3G MicroCell calling plans at purchase are also eligible to receive a $100 mail-in-rebate toward the purchase of AT&T 3G MicroCell – effectively making the device about $50. Customers who also purchase a new line of broadband service with AT&T (DSL or U-verse 1.5MB or higher) are also eligible for $50 via mail-in-rebate– effectively making the device about $100.  If a customer is eligible for both rebate options, the customer will be able to get the device for $0, after mail-in rebate.

Ooh, so if I downgrade my cable broadband to 6Mbit/s DSL or promise to pay you $240 next year  in monthly fees for the privilege of using my broadband connection to make your shitty network better, I can get a few bucks off the device? That sounds like a great deal guys! Thanks a bundle AT&T!

*AT&T imposes: a Regulatory Cost Recovery Charge of up to $1.25 to help defray costs incurred in complying with obligations and charges imposed by State and Federal telecom regulations; State and Federal Universal Service charges; and surcharges for government assessments on AT&T. These fees are not taxes or government-required charges. (Edit: plus a whole lot more fine print)

Oh, also we're going to charge you $1.25 (probably a month) because we can. It's not required, but if we put that number down toward the bottom of the bill, with all the other tax crap, most of you probably won't notice. 

So, here's my problem. A femtocell is a device whose sole purpose is to help fill gaps in wireless networks. Instead of using it as a way to turn unhappy customers into happy customers, AT&T is treating the femtocell as another way to squeeze their already victimized customer for another $20 a month. It even seems like a good deal, especially the first time your teenage kid blew out your minutes and landed you a $500 phone bill. But, AT&T, times they're a-changin'. 

One of  those  carriers who aren't sitting on an iPhone monopoly and praying that the 3G network doesn't completely crumble before 4G is ready (you have been investing in 4G, right? You sure as hell aren't spending anything keeping 3G awesome), are going to stop screwing customers by billing based on antiquated concepts like voice minutes used and text messages sent. After all, do you buy gas based on the number of miles driven? Do you pay for food by the calorie? No. Instead they'll switch to a measure that actually makes sense-- billing customers based on the actual amount of data that they use. And when that happens, your $15 unlimited texting plan and $40 pseudo-unlimited data plan will make you long for the days when shitty 3G connections in San Francisco and Manhattan were your biggest problems. 

In the meantime, I'll continue taking calls in the bathroom. Thanks anyway, AT&T.    
branton March 24, 2010 at 2:32 p.m.
Amen.  This is the kind of article I bet you wish you could have written while at MaxPC.  Keep up the good work. :)
neo1piv014on March 24, 2010 at 2:35 p.m.
Hm. I wonder if Will is secretly channeling Gordon. Still, this is ridiculous. I'm surprised they don't make their customers rent the tools, dump trucks and backhoes whenever they want to install a new cell tower.  This is the kind of thing they should give away to customers that live in areas that are supposedly inside the service area. Tmobile of Albuquerque, please take note.
litrockon March 24, 2010 at 2:35 p.m.
Thank you for this.  Not only is this enlightening, it's hilarious as well. 
billygoat117on March 24, 2010 at 2:38 p.m.
It always brightens my day to see people recognize how insane AT&T is. Those Luke Wilson ads make me want to kill myself. Although have you noticed how they never actually refute the assertion that their coverage sucks? They basically just say, "Our coverage may be terrible, but when it works, it does better things!" Um, that doesn't actually balance out, guys.
Maxtronon March 24, 2010 at 2:41 p.m.
I look forward to the day when my iPhone will be free from the shackles of AT&T.
neo1piv014on March 24, 2010 at 2:42 p.m.
Hmmm...I wonder what would happen if AT&T merged with someone like WalMart....
"Sure, only five of our stores sell anything at all, but if you're willing to go to the AT&Mart in one of five major metropolitan areas, you can get everything you'd normally expect from a sanely run store."
Bummeyon March 24, 2010 at 2:47 p.m.
You spend 12 hours per day in your bathroom?
cohenjoron March 24, 2010 at 2:48 p.m.

Verizon offers a similar device.  At my parents home, my Dad called Verizon, complained about the lack of service, and they actually sent him this device to use.  For free. 
 
The notion of AT&T charging for this is absolutely ridiculous.
neo1piv014on March 24, 2010 at 2:48 p.m.
@Bummey: 
They wrote the Uncle John's Bathroom Reader for a reason.
Optikalon March 24, 2010 at 2:52 p.m.
This has been the discussion since the first announcement of AT&T's femtocell.  Buying the hardware for a reasonable ($50 or less) cost is one thing.  But for them to charge you to use your own home internet connection on top of the hardware cost? It shows you how in touch with reality AT&T is in general.  And, on top of that, to take away from your wireless minutes for using it on the femtocell in your home...Ludicrous. 
 
Welcome to the AT&T family, kids.
NoXiouson March 24, 2010 at 3:02 p.m.
What? I guess I should be glad I live in a European Nanny Nation :-P
We don't get crap like this! 
MassiveDuckon March 24, 2010 at 3:06 p.m.
This is scathing... and I love it!   
I love paying for other peoples mistakes, so I am in full support of this product!
Zaphon March 24, 2010 at 3:30 p.m.
Wow, I had no idea cell reception in the US was such a pain in the arse. And aren't you in a pretty populated city too? Shouldn't that mean the cover is great?
 
Credit where credit due, the cheek of AT&T in this press release is amazing "We're going to charge you to use your phone, on a service you already pay for, to make calls over your broadband connection (using up your transfer allowance) and it will eat up your minutes. Oh and we want $150 for the trouble".
 
Do you think AT&T will supply the lube before they bend you over?
Monkeyman04on March 24, 2010 at 3:52 p.m.
What new? If your over the age of 16 you should know that corporations are nothing but money hungry douches. Everything they (the corporations) do is based on how much money they make and they don't care about the customer, until it goes to bite them in the ass.
Fripplebubbyon March 24, 2010 at 3:56 p.m.
3G doesn't even EXIST where I live. Only Altell and Verizon are carriers here...
Gonmogon March 24, 2010 at 4:09 p.m.
Wow. They want to make you smile before they bend you over. With out the lube...This is the sole thing that kept me from getting a iphone. At&ts plans just suck for me. I hope EVO will fill the iphone gap i have.
Redeyeon March 24, 2010 at 4:10 p.m.
I guess I don't live in a crappy coverage area and don't really get it.  My father-in-law lives in the sticks and ATT is the best coverage for that area, and you can only make phone calls from the front half of the house.  This sounds like a great idea, except the fact that you also can't get reliable broadband.  So really this is to fill in the coverage that is lacking that shows up on AT&T's map as covered.  I can't help but feel that AT&T is charging for something that I'm already paying for.  T-mobile doesn't have the largest footprint, but their billing methods (I buy unlocked phones, so I pay less monthly... BRILLIANT!) seem more reasonable.  By the way, with T-mobile you can add a "Home" line that is unlimited minutes that works through broadband, and only costs an additional $5 a month.  Hmmm. 
 
EDIT: I take back the comment on the T-mobile home, $5 etc.  I distinctly recall seeing this in one of their stores not a month ago, but can't find anything on their webpage now.  Maybe someone can confirm my mad ramblings.   
 
EDIT2: I fail.  It is called @home, costs $10 a month for unlimited nationwide calls.  Uses a new number... still.
bretthancockon March 24, 2010 at 4:37 p.m.
Another reason that cell phone companies are awful.  Verizon charges an EXTRA 15 bucks on top of data for GPS, AT&T's 3G coverage is ass(except in Seattle), TMobile's network sucks, and so on.  My advise to anyone without a cell phone at this point is find one you like and be ready to have a very valid reason to complain about whatever network you are on.
mainiacvanmanon March 24, 2010 at 4:41 p.m.
@cohenjor:  
 what was the device called exactly? my brother could use something like that, his house is a black hole for cell signals
cohenjoron March 24, 2010 at 4:49 p.m.
@mainiacvanman said:

" @cohenjor:   what was the device called exactly? my brother could use something like that, his house is a black hole for cell signals "


http://news.vzw.com/news/2009/01/pr2009-01-26c.html 
 
It looks like Verizon also charges for it, but through persuasive customer support discussions, he ended up getting it for absolutely free.  I think my Dad even offered to pay for it beforehand, but the representative on the phone just said he/she could send it at no charge. 
 
Your mileage may vary :-)
How To Rip DVDs to Play on Any Device—For Free!

Our ultimate DVD copying guide shows you how to use Handbrake to rip discs for playback on your laptop, Xbox, PS3, iPhone, Zune, netbook, iPad, PSP, iPod, and pretty much anything else

Tested: Apple Mac OS X Lion

The $30 upgrade from Snow Leopard seems like a no-brainer, but that's not the full story. Read the official Tested review.

Apple iPad 2 Review

Our definitive review of the iPad 2.

Tested: Nvidia GeForce GTX 580 Video Card

The green machine comes back swinging.

Apple iPad Wi-Fi Review

Apple's device isn't magical, but it is going to make the tablet a real category--for better or for worse

Video: How To Build the Best $1500 Gaming PC, Step-by-Step

Do you like saving money? What about playing PC games? Have you ever considered building your own PC? We show you exactly what you need to know to build an awesome $1500 gaming PC.

How To Build an Awesome $500 Windows Home Server

We pick the best parts to build a lean media backup and streaming machine.

The Best Android Phone for Your Network (February 2011)

Don't get locked in with the wrong phone.

Living with Technology: Building My Annual Production PC

Is in January yet? Then it’s time for a new production system. Here's what Loyd put in his daily work and gaming rig.

Report: 2GHz Samsung Tablet with 2560x1600 Display at MWC This Month

In one month, the first ARM Cortex-A15 device could be unveiled. Sounds like Samsung will be going all out.

The Best Android Smartphone for Your Network (January 2012)

Can you wait for the next big thing, or is it time to settle?

How Android OEMs Miss the Mark with TV Commercials

A one minute Super Bowl commercial is wasted if the ad doesn't win any converts.

Will These Be the Major Technology Trends of 2012?

A design firm predicts the course of technology for 2012. These are big-picture ideas, not products: you won't find smart fridges or smartphones on the list.

AMD Radeon 7950 Benchmarks Measure Up to GTX 580 Performance

The second-tier 7000 series card offers cooler, quieter performance than the GTX 580 of 2011, but performance between the two is competitive, depending on the game.

How Security Cameras Can Provide Anonymous Shopper Statistics

A video processing company takes security camera footage and turns it into useful data for retailers.

Intel Updates Sandy Bridge Family with 7 New Desktop CPUs

Sandy Bridge gets seven new processors, including a trio of i5 CPUs without built-in HD graphics.

Living with Technology: Building My Annual Production PC

Is in January yet? Then it’s time for a new production system. Here's what Loyd put in his daily work and gaming rig.

Kinect for Windows Launches, Here's How it Differs from Xbox

Kinect for Windows leaves beta, gets an official retail release and a new and improved SDK.

Windows Phone 8 "Apollo" Features Revealed in Insider Video

Pocketnew spills some juicy secrets on the Apollo Windows Phone 7 update, due out late this year. Windows Phone 7 becomes Windows Phone 8.

How Many In-Store Shoppers Actually Check Prices Using Their Phones?

A new study looks at how the ability to compare in-store and online prices affects purchasing decisions.

Neil Young Worked with Steve Jobs on 24-Bit Audio Standard

A famous CEO and a famous musician talked about music, compression and a potential 24-bit iPod.

Report: 2GHz Samsung Tablet with 2560x1600 Display at MWC This Month

In one month, the first ARM Cortex-A15 device could be unveiled. Sounds like Samsung will be going all out.

Here's What's New in Mozilla's Just-Released Firefox 10

Firefox 10 has moved out of beta and into full release. Here's what's different that you should care about.

Microsoft Tweaks Windows 8 File Management Due to User Feedback

In the first of a series of posts based on customer feedback, Microsoft lists some tweaks made to Explorer, the Ribbon, and copying files.