Quick and Dirty Guide to HD TV Tuners for Your PC
In the coming weeks, HDHomeRun hopes to have their CableCARD tuner ironed out and submitted to CableLabs for certification, which would give them enough of a head start to release a final product in time for the holidays. Unlike the version that was shown at CES earlier this year, the current prototype now sports four tuners instead of three, although one of those is for out of band data and isn't capable of recording HD. But hey, that still leaves you with three tuners to work with, plus a coax connector, USB port (for the Tuning Adapter, nothing else), and a single CableCARD slot to manage all three tuners. Despite the additional tuner, HDHomeRun still plans to sell the card for $249. 
 
That's a compelling price point for so many HD tuners on one device, but what are some of the technologies you should be looking for if you're in the market for an HD TV tuner for your PC right now? 
 

USB vs PCI vs PCI-E

The biggest question you need to ask yourself is where you plan on using your HD tuner. For mobile warriors always on the go, a USB tuner makes the most sense. You can try shopping for an ExpressCard tuner, but these tend to be hard to find, and unlike a USB tuner, you won't have the option of plugging it into a desktop or HTPC should you retire your notebook.
 
For stationary setups, a PCI-E or PCI tuner should be at the top of your list. For one, you won't have to avoid bumping into a permanently affixed USB flash drive jutting out from your case, but more importantly, internal tuner cards tend have more features and accessories (like a remote), though this isn't always the case. Less important is the choice between a standard PCI form factor and PCI-E. Even though a PCI Express interface offers far more bandwidth, this isn't the same as shopping for a gaming card where the faster slot automatically wins. Either type of port is sufficient for watching TV on your PC.
 

HDTV Resolutions

Not all high definition is created equal, so even though a tuner card may be billed as HD, it might not be up to snuff with your display Here are the different resolutions and types to choose from: 

  • 1080p: 1920x1080, progressive scan
  • 1080i: 1920x1080, interlaced
  • 720p: 1280x720, progressive scan
 
 Interlaced video
 Interlaced video
Progressive scan means that all the lines of a frame are drawn in sequence, whereas interlaced scanning divides the horizontal lines into odd and even numbers and alternately refreshes them. Progressive scan typically results in smoother action with less flicker.
 

Software and Compatibility

Often times when shopping PC components, any software bundle ends being of little value and we've almost trained ourselves to overlook this part of the equation. But when buying a TV tuner card, the software makes all the difference in the world. It pays to do your research here and see what others have to say about the included software, such as whether or not it's easy to use and what features are included, like time-shifting (pausing live TV), scheduling (programming the tuner to record a specific show or time slot), and other DVR features.
 
Don't assume every HD tuner card works with Windows Media Center, either. Not all of them do, though there's good reason to invest in one that does. Windows Media Center supports a whole bunch of analog and digital TV signals, including ATSC, QAM, ISDB, DVB-T, and DVB-S. For more on what each of these are, see Microsoft's support page here.
 

QAM Decoding

There are two ways of receiving digital cable - either Over The Air (OTA) or through a cable receiver. A QAM (quadrature amplitude modulation) tuner allows you to receive unencrypted/unscrambled digital programming from your cable company without the need for a digital cable box, which means you're almost always limited to local broadcasts. Nevertheless, if you want to receive HD signals through cable, you'll need a tuner with QAM support.
8 Comments
tom032792 on May 13, 2010
I don't mean to come of with an attitude, and correct me if I'm wrong, but this article says that 720p is interlaced. I thought the "p" meant progressive.
norman on May 13, 2010
@tom032792: fixed. thanks for the catch!
tom032792 on May 13, 2010
No problem. Long time fan of Max PC, and merged over here. Keep up the good work guys. 
simian online on May 14, 2010
Sigh I wish the CRTC would enforce the providers here to support cablecards.
an909 on May 14, 2010

This is a great introduction, but I hope you will follow-up with some reviews of the popular TV Tuners, as well as some instruction for optimizing performance. 
I recently installed a Hauppauge WinTV HVR-1600 and have been dissapointed with the resolution using full screen mode.  Additionally, the HD channels available using QAM tuner seem to change every other week withour rhyme or reason. 
As more of us embrace the notion of consuming media using our PCs, your insight becomes much more valuable. 
Keep up the good work.
TheAdmin on May 14, 2010
I recently cancelled my cable and was looking to run TV from over the air... I bought a Haupage WinTV-HVR-950Q and it's amazing! I have it plugged into my computer and an antenna in the window. It's able to get all the major networks in crystal clear HD, which is a huge plus. The antenna that came with it was pretty decent, but I wanted a stronger one so I bought a 10 dollar RCA Antenna from best buy and it definitely did the trick.  I stream all my content to my Xbox 360 using windows media center - which means I have DVR capabilites and everything... it's the perfect solution if you want to kill cable (and find that you watch mostly broadcast shows). 
 
My list of equipment: 
WinTV-HVR-950Q 
RCA Indoor Antenna 
Xbox 360 
Windows Media Center 
 
I can't recommend this enough and everyone is surprised how well it works and how awesome it looks when they see it. The HD signal over the air is, in my opinion, better then my cancelled cable provider (Brighthouse networks). Getting the TV tuner and antenna will cost you about 80 bucks... which after a month or two of no cable pays for itself if you already have a PC and an Xbox 360.
evil_gordita on May 14, 2010
This is actually kind of timely since I've just recently retired the TV in my bedroom (selling it at the yard sale this weekend) and I was wanting to add a tuner to my desktop to replace the TV.
 
Further down the line I want to put a HTPC in the family room.  We have digital cable and I wonder if I could use an HTPC to replace the setop box completely for things like VOD and etc.   I don't want to have to keep both the set-top and HTPC connected to the TV if I can help it.
wonko33 on May 18, 2010
Are you guys going to review the Centon at the end of the month? 
http://www.cetoncorp.com/products.php
  • Type the words above including the space. Get new words?
Errors will go here
Post Reply
Processing....
Popular News
How To Rip DVDs to Play on Any Device—For Free!

Our ultimate DVD copying guide shows you how to use Handbrake to rip discs for playback on your laptop, Xbox, PS3, iPhone, Zune, netbook, iPad, PSP, iPod, and pretty much anything else

Video: How To Build the Best $1500 Gaming PC, Step-by-Step

Do you like saving money? What about playing PC games? Have you ever considered building your own PC? We show you exactly what you need to know to build an awesome $1500 gaming PC.

How To Build an Awesome $500 Windows Home Server

We pick the best parts to build a lean media backup and streaming machine.

Apple iPad Wi-Fi Review

Apple's device isn't magical, but it is going to make the tablet a real category--for better or for worse

Nexus One vs HTC Desire vs HTC Incredible: What's the Difference?

HTC is releasing more Android phones all the time, but is there a difference?

How To Steal Mac OS's Best Features for Windows

Windows 7's Aero is a fine UI, but there are just a few things it's missing. Here's how to steal some of Mac OS's features.

How To Rip a Blu-Ray Movie with Just One Click

The MakeMKV utility decrypts and rips a Blu-Ray disc with just one click, preserving the original video quality of the source file.

How To Stream All of Your Video Files to iPhone and iPad

Get your DVD rips off your computer and play them on a mobile device, without having to convert them beforehand.

Apple Fall Event 2010 Discussion Thread: iPods and AppleTV

Discuss Apple's Fall Event announcements here!

What Are You Playing This Weekend?

The weekend's upon us, and like any good nerds, we're spending the last days of summer holed up in our houses playing board and video games. What are you playing this weekend?

iPod Nano 6G vs 5G: Everything You Need to Know

The iPod nano is ready to go running. Are you?

Your Shiny New Xbox 360 Controller is Already Outdated

Transforming d-pad makes it more than just a cosmetic update.

Everything You Should Know about Apple's New iPod Touch

All views expressed in this deck are the sole property of the internet rumor machine.

Why the Obama Administration's Stance on Piracy Sidesteps Complicated Issues

Addressing an audience of workers in the music industry, Commerce Secretary Gary Locke reaffirmed the Obama administration's commitment to cracking down on media piracy on the Internet.

Living with Technology: Two Mice for One Desktop PC

What would drive a man to use two mice for one computer?

Android Market Roundup: 5 Apps to Put a Smile on Your Phone

It's the weekly Android Market Roundup.

Apple Fall Event 2010 Discussion Thread: iPods and AppleTV

Discuss Apple's Fall Event announcements here!

What Are You Playing This Weekend?

The weekend's upon us, and like any good nerds, we're spending the last days of summer holed up in our houses playing board and video games. What are you playing this weekend?

Your Shiny New Xbox 360 Controller is Already Outdated

Transforming d-pad makes it more than just a cosmetic update.

Never Give Up: Microsoft May Be Working on One More Zune

Just in time for Apple's new iPod Touch announcement, a rumor is brewing indicating that Microsoft is going to give the Zune another go.

Why the Obama Administration's Stance on Piracy Sidesteps Complicated Issues

Addressing an audience of workers in the music industry, Commerce Secretary Gary Locke reaffirmed the Obama administration's commitment to cracking down on media piracy on the Internet.

The New AppleTV: $99, No Apps, All About Streaming

The original AppleTV was a device with an identity crisis. The latest update aims to fix that, and a whole lot more.

Living with Technology: Two Mice for One Desktop PC

What would drive a man to use two mice for one computer?

Everything You Should Know about Apple's New iPod Touch

All views expressed in this deck are the sole property of the internet rumor machine.