Tested News

Philips Adds 3D to 21:9 TV, But Who's Going to Buy It?

This TV may be beautiful, but we're not sure who would spend $5000 on it.

Nothing says extravagant like a 56” 21:9 cinema display--except, maybe, a 58” 21:9 cinema display with 3D. Philips has unveiled the 2010 rendition of its ridiculously wide cinema display with a few aesthetic improvements and a whole lot of new stuff going on behind the LCD. All of the internal enhancements are designed to make the TV handle 3D images without sacrificing picture quality.

Because 3D tends to darken images, Philips installed its Bright Pro technology, which uses 1500 LEDs to selectively brighten portions of the screen without washing out the blacks. The Active 3D technology (which requires a special pair of glasses, naturally) supposedly synchronizes the lenses with what’s on screen to maximize the 3D effect and minimize crosstalk. Theoretically, reducing crosstalk means stopping the image bleedthrough from one channel to the other.

Finally, the icing on the cake is Philips’ Ambilight technology, which projects light onto the walls around the device to make it look better and brighter. The Platinum 21:9 Cinema display is obviously an awesome TV, but with a UK price tag of about £3,500, or more than $5000, we have to wonder: who is the market for 21:9 displays?

3D as a display format seems to raise more ire than eyebrows, and with high prices and annoying glasses consumer adoption of 3D sets is slow. The 21:9 display, which accurately depicts the 2.4:1 film aspect ratio without black bars at the top and bottom, is clearly for cinephiles only.

But will movie junkies (even the rich ones) want it? Philips’ display stretches 16:9 content out to the full width of the screen with “highly advanced auto-formatting technology.” If we’re talking about the hardest of the hardcore willing to drop thousands of dollars for a TV, why wouldn’t they opt for a projector, instead?

Apparently last year’s cinema display wasn’t a complete flop, since Philips has made heavy revisions and added 3D to the picture. Still, some movies today are filmed natively at 16:9, and it’s the dominant aspect ratio for television programs and gaming. Is there any reason to upgrade to a 21:9 display when an even larger 16:9 display could be had for thousands left? Give us you take.
neo1piv014on Sept. 2, 2010 at 4:42 p.m.
Does that light projection feature remind anyone else of that episode of Family Guy where they hire a really ugly girl to stand next to Meg so she'll look hotter by comparison? I guess it makes sense to sort of silhouette the TV to make it look brighter, but that just cracks me up. Still won't help if there's something shining at the screen.
Jadeskyeon Sept. 2, 2010 at 5:01 p.m.
Tested just did that thing where i was searching for ultra wide aspect TVs and i found this one then i went to tested and found a news story on it. 
 
Freaky!
connorbevanson Sept. 2, 2010 at 5:11 p.m.
For the love of god, use 2.39. It's not 2.4! 
Now that my duty as a pedant is fulfilled I'll actually participate in some discussion. 
@neo1piv014:  The light projection feature as I understand it isn't really there to improve the brightness, but rather enhance apparent contrast, reduce eyestrain and backlight bleeding, and (according to Phillips marketing) "It completely immerses you in the action, makes the screen seem larger."
cowgodon Sept. 2, 2010 at 5:21 p.m.
directors, game makers and technology manufacturers need to come together and pick one god damn aspect ratio across the board.  this is getting ri-god-damn-diculous.  can't we all just have 16x9 screens so nobody has to see black bars, ever?  please?
Newtenon Sept. 2, 2010 at 5:37 p.m.
@cowgod said:

" directors, game makers and technology manufacturers need to come together and pick one god damn aspect ratio across the board.  this is getting ri-god-damn-diculous.  can't we all just have 16x9 screens so nobody has to see black bars, ever?  please? "

This! Thank god I'm not the only one who thinks this. The 16:10 aspect ratio baffles me, but this new TV is even more ridiculous, who the hell even has any content in 21:9, let alone in 3D too? It's ridiculous.
enemymouseon Sept. 2, 2010 at 6:31 p.m.
Tvs should stick to accurate colour, and original image-shape. Stretched images are for people who just don't give a shit about the picture. I know some people hate the black bars but they are wrong. Let the directors and cinematographers decide how the movie should look please.
 
And as mentioned before, where is there any content released in ultra wide format with a full 1080 horizontal lines? 2.39:1 movies are letterboxed into 16x9 so your never even seeing an honest 1080 lines on this thing anyway. Doesn't sound very cinephile to me.
 
Oh and 3d sucks =P
 
Sorry to rant but this stuff gets my goat!
Scooperon Sept. 3, 2010 at 5:08 a.m.
I'm going to get 3 of these for my gaming rig.
RonaldBryanon Sept. 3, 2010 at 7:40 a.m.
@connorbevans said:

" For the love of god, use 2.39. It's not 2.4!  "

But then how can I watch Deja Vu in the full 2.40:1 aspect ratio that it is on the Blu-Ray in? Someone needs to make a 21.6:9 aspect ratio TV, STAT! (Of course, that might be the actual aspect ratio of the TV, and they just say 21 because decimals get too confusing.) 
 
And for the aspect ratio and size, it comes down to where you want the black bars on your screen. This screen will only have bars on the sides (unless you have a DVD that's not anamorphic). And of course, any movie above about 1.85:1 will have a larger image than a tradition 16:9 TV at the same 58" size. Granted, depending on how the blu-rays are encoded, some will play their larger aspect ratio in their full 1080p resolution on this TV while others (much like those non-anamorphic DVDs) will only be able to scale up. So, who is this TV for? People with a lot of extra money who want a really wide TV that stands out versus other modern TVs and has 3D capabilities. So, if I had a ton of disposable income, I might buy it (which will be never.)
GrantButleron Sept. 3, 2010 at 9:25 a.m.
I'd pay £1500 for a TV max, not gonna be spending £3.5k, just too expensive and a waste of money when something better will come out the next month. I heard TV's with 3D from out th ebox will come by the end of the year, so just wait for that.
connorbevanson Sept. 3, 2010 at 9:41 a.m.
Phillips claims that it is, in fact, 2.39. I suppose they were approximating. "For a true cinematic widescreen TV viewing experience that perfectly matches the original 21:9 (2.39:1) film format." 
It's odd that the Blu Ray is in 2.4, because as I understood it Deja Vu was in 2.35/2.39. I'm assuming that the Blu Ray overscans? I know that for some movies such as The Dark Knight (2.39) they author the disc in 2.4.
TheRedDeath25on Sept. 4, 2010 at 9:11 a.m.
TV is getting ridiculous . Back in the day tv's lasted about 10 years now they want us to go out and by a tv every 6 months by adding useless technologies like 3d.  I bought my HDTV  about a year ago and until it is broke and can't be used I am not going to buy another one .
How To Rip DVDs to Play on Any Device—For Free!

Our ultimate DVD copying guide shows you how to use Handbrake to rip discs for playback on your laptop, Xbox, PS3, iPhone, Zune, netbook, iPad, PSP, iPod, and pretty much anything else

Tested: Apple Mac OS X Lion

The $30 upgrade from Snow Leopard seems like a no-brainer, but that's not the full story. Read the official Tested review.

Apple iPad 2 Review

Our definitive review of the iPad 2.

Tested: Nvidia GeForce GTX 580 Video Card

The green machine comes back swinging.

Apple iPad Wi-Fi Review

Apple's device isn't magical, but it is going to make the tablet a real category--for better or for worse

Video: How To Build the Best $1500 Gaming PC, Step-by-Step

Do you like saving money? What about playing PC games? Have you ever considered building your own PC? We show you exactly what you need to know to build an awesome $1500 gaming PC.

How To Build an Awesome $500 Windows Home Server

We pick the best parts to build a lean media backup and streaming machine.

The Best Android Phone for Your Network (February 2011)

Don't get locked in with the wrong phone.

New High-DPI OS X UI Elements Give Hope for High-Resolution Macs

The iPad 3 is expected to offer a high resolution display; should we expect the same from the MacBook Pro line?

$35 Raspberry Pi Computer Enters Production, Due February 20th

Raspberry Pi's pocket-size Linux computer is inches away from real availability.

Nokia Explains What Makes Its Lumia ClearBlack Screens Unique

Nokia's new displays use polarizers and filters to limit screen reflectance.

AT&T Unreasonably Throttling Users with Unlimited Data Plans

AT&T ignores its responsibility to keep users informed while clearly pushing them towards tiered data plans.

Tested: Google Chrome Beta for Android Ice Cream Sandwich Phones

It's Chrome, shrunken down and blazing-fast on Android.

Windows 8 Metro App Multitasking Will Mimic Mobile Apps

Microsoft details the behavior of suspended and background apps in the WinRT Metro environment.

Logitech Announces a Touch Mouse: Where Have We Seen This Before?

Like the Logitech Wireless Touchpad, the Touch 600M looks an awful lot like an Apple input device with a new skin.

Here's What You Should Expect from Windows 8's Consumer Preview

At the end of February, Windows 8 will be previewed and available for download.

AT&T Unreasonably Throttling Users with Unlimited Data Plans

AT&T ignores its responsibility to keep users informed while clearly pushing them towards tiered data plans.

Windows 8 Start Button May Be Replaced by a Hot Corner and Charms

A recent build of Windows 8 shows the desktop Super Bar minus one Start button.

How Android OEMs Miss the Mark with TV Commercials

A one minute Super Bowl commercial is wasted if the ad doesn't win any converts.

Smart Earphones Know Which Ears They're In, Adjusts Channels Accordingly

A Japanese research project uses proximity sensors to detect which ear earbuds are in and change stereo channels to compensate.

How HTC Squandered Its Android Lead and Had a Mediocre 2011

HTC is experiencing a worrying slide in sales, and here's why.

HDR Photography: Accurate Tone-Mapping or Photo Manipulation?

The use of high dynamic range in photojournalism sparks an argument about digital manipulation.

Tested: Google Chrome Beta for Android Ice Cream Sandwich Phones

It's Chrome, shrunken down and blazing-fast on Android.

Why Apple's A5 Chip in the iPhone 4S is Needed for Siri

Siri only runs on the iPhone 4S thanks to improved, integrated noise cancellation technology integrated into the A5 processor.