Cut Energy Costs: Five Power-Saving Myths Evaluated
Computers can get pretty small, but that doesn't mean they don't know to draw down a whole lot of power. Laptops and desktops both need to draw fuel from somewhere, and sometimes, the amount of electricity being pumped through your PSU is a lot more than you'd think.
 
Whether you want to lower your hydro bill, or reduce your carbon footprint, lowering the load inflicted by your Mac or PC is a great place to start. While it was once taken for granted that PCs required a lot of power, these days we know differently. With a greater interest in power saving and conservation, users have devised some interesting ideas on how to lighten their electrical load. Some are fact, and some are fiction, and the hard part is knowing which is which.
 
Today we're going to debunk some power-saving myths and lay down the cold, hard truth.

Claim: Using Dark Wallpaper and Screensavers Conserves Power

There was a time when people believed that Google's homepage was actually wasting us all energy. White, some argued, was actually harder for most computer screen's to display, and black-heavy background would save us all a great deal of power. The problem is, that only holds true for older, CRT-based displays. As Google so eloquently stated in a blog post on the situation, "on flat-panel monitors (already estimated to be 75% of the market), displaying black may actually *increase* energy usage." Ouch. 
  
Verdict: False

Claim: An Idle Computer Uses Less Power

Some people believe that leaving a functioning computer on all night will consume just as much power as it does during the day. For the most part, however, this isn't exactly true. Most operating systems now incorporate a variety of power saving functions that tone down your power consumption when not in use. Hard drives can be set to spin down into an idle state, network functions disabled, USB devices put to sleep, and on some laptops and desktop machines, even have the CPU step down to a lower clock speed. All of these together can help to greatly reduce the power consumption of an idle machine.

Verdict: True

Claim: Hibernation Is Better Than Standby

Standby, as everyone knows, puts your Mac or PC into a low-powered state, with just enough juice to keep your data in RAM. Hibernation, on the other hand, dumps this data to your hard drive, allowing power usage to be cut almost completely. Or so you'd think. Both modes cut power consumption to only a few watts, but the actual difference is almost negligible. In fact, the difference between hibernation and standby isn't as much about power reduction at all, but data safety and state persistence.

Verdict: False

Claim: Cycling The Power On/Off Uses More Energy Than Constant Uptime

The saying goes that each time a computer is cycled off, and then on again, it consumes more power than simply leaving the computer on. In some ways, this is partially true. A regular boot process includes polling USB devices, accessing hard drives and handling network traffic — all heightened activity that might not occur constantly when fully booted. However, as we explained above, the relatively low-power idle process of most modern computers is more than enough to make up for this ever-so-slight bump in usage, meaning you can probably cycle that power button as much as you wish.

Verdict: False

Claim: Solid State Drives Consume Less Power Than Conventional Platters

Common knowledge dictates that SSD's are not only fast, but great at reducing power consumption, improving your battery life in the process. Considering what we know about hard drives, this conclusion seems to make sense. SSD's, after all, have no moving parts compared to their platter and head-based predecessors. However, Tom's Hardware has done a great job at proving that this is simply not true. While a typical hard drive has varying power requirements, depending on how much the drive head must move across the platters, SSDs do not. They are either active, or idle.

To put it simply, "They will draw their maximum power level constantly when in use, and as a consequence, simply spend more total time drawing maximum power than conventional drives." As a result, some manufacturers have begun to include power-saving capabilities in certain drives — the trick is finding one with the feature.

Verdict: False 
 
Images via Flickr users Rakesh Ashok and hongiiv.
18 Comments
ch13696 on July 30, 2010
So at this point, the only way to consume less energy is to put are PC into sleep mode?
Dezinus on July 30, 2010
Interesting. This would probably be more relevant to me a handful of years ago. My PC sleeps/wakes so quickly nowdays that I just do that all the time.
TheLepper on July 30, 2010
lol. using black wallpapers XD XD
Eisen on July 30, 2010
hibernation is better than standby for notebooks as standby will eat the battery still, while hibernation will not.  It may not matter as much for a Desktop, but for a notebook it does.
 
I use black backgrounds not for power savings, but because it reduces the amount of glare that I see on my glasses (and yes i know i need to get a pair for anti-glare).
TheLepper on July 30, 2010
WHAT? i just read the last part. steady state my A**.
nabokovfan87 on July 30, 2010

You really should do one about PSU ratings, effeciency and how buying a large wattage hard drive can lead to more effecient and less power usage.
Bigandtasty on July 30, 2010
At first I saw my username in that screenshot and thought "I have a Mac?" =o
Greg818 on July 30, 2010
@bagels: I agree that not all SSDs consume less than any HDD, but if you compare what's comparable (low power HDD to low power SSD, hi speed SSD vs hi speed HDD), SSD consume less. I've been searching for these info as I'm willing to upgrade my laptop to SSD. For my particular case, I'm running a WD scorpio blue, low power 2.5" HDD, which drains 2W while idle and 2.5W under load, while the equivalent from Intel, X-25M, only requires 150mW under load and only half when idle (which happens after 25ms). That is a huge difference for me. And tom's hardware article is from 2 years ago, a lot of water has gone under the bridge since then. 
 
Edit: Forgot the Intel SSD datasheet (it's a PDF)
damnboyadvance on July 30, 2010
I'm sure that hibernation would save a little energy over stand by if you were planning to be away for a long time, but didn't want to actually shut it down. Either way, I still put my computer on stand-by every night.
RonaldBryan on July 30, 2010
The cycling the power on/off is just like the people who claim you will conserve on gas by not turning your car off when making a quick stop. Really, you wind up using about the same. Absolutely right on the standby thing. I just close the lid on my laptop which puts it into standby at night and it barely eats up anything.
@Eisen said:

" hibernation is better than standby for notebooks as standby will eat the battery still, while hibernation will not.  It may not matter as much for a Desktop, but for a notebook it does. "

On my Macbook at least I haven't noticed a big difference between the two. Granted, standby will eat some battery, but for half a day, it's not even five percent of the battery. But then Macs have really good battery lives. I have gone over six hours of use with this unplugged, while my old Vaio was licky to get to two before the battery died. But then you can set up different power options. Such as closing the lid putting it in standby for when it is plugged in and pushing the power button putting it in hibernation for when it is not plugged in. 
 
Although, either way, it doesn't matter since the article was about energy-saving methods to reduce your energy bill.
Eisen on July 30, 2010
@RonaldBryan:  I don't leave my laptop plugged in and as such I'd prefer not having standby eating the battery.  In fact, I do not leave any chargers plugged in that are not actively in use.  If you want to save power, then unplugging unused adapters can reduce energy use and if you think of this on less of a personal level and that of a national level and then you would see the energy savings would be quite vast.  It may be a small watt usage in your overall home, but it can make a difference over a year especially if you are like my household where there are multiple laptops,  desktops (4 desktops, and 6 laptops) , and a variety of mobile devices around that are used. 
 
I've knocked off $25 a month by not leaving things plugged or switching off surge protectors not in use to cut off power to prevent phantom usage.  It is a bigger deal than some care to believe.
RonaldBryan on July 30, 2010
@Eisen said:

" @RonaldBryan:    
I've knocked off $25 a month by not leaving things plugged or switching off surge protectors not in use to cut off power to prevent phantom usage. It is a bigger deal than some care to believe. "

Well, of course it's an issue. Especially in the US. Most other countries actually have on/off switches on their wall plugs so when they are not needed you can turn them off to save on energy. Here in the US we do not as no one has jumped on the energy conservation bandwagon in a big way to help bring about reform in these things. And we currently have only four laptops, one desktop, three televisions, four game systems, two cable boxes, two surround systems, and a stand up freezer in a two story townhouse which would be draining energy and the average energy bill is still only $25 a month. The biggest issue I have found has been less with electronics, and more with not running the air conditioning at a low temperature when there is no one in the house. That alone cut over $50 from the average monthly payment. I do wonder about energy consumption for a charging battery laptop or cell phone versus one with a full battery. My assumption would be there would be no real difference but you never know.
Greg818 on July 31, 2010
@RonaldBryan said: 
Well, of course it's an issue. Especially in the US. Most other countries actually have on/off switches on their wall plugs so when they are not needed you can turn them off to save on energy."
You're probably going to laugh, but we don't have that in France neither. Probably because of the very low electricity price as EDF (electricity provider) is a state owned entity.
emenHX on July 31, 2010
What to save costs? switch off or unplug the damn thing, boot time takes less than a minute anyway.
Th3_James on Aug. 1, 2010
I always put my laptop and desktop in sleep. takes 4 seconds to get back to what i'm doing, and I don't care about power consumption. 
Grimace on Aug. 2, 2010
I've found leaving my computer off uses no power at all but I have a really hard time getting it to do anything useful.
1Colin1 on Aug. 2, 2010

I just turn my PC off at night, not to save power or anything like that but simple it's too noisy for me to be able to sleep with it on, also the heat it outputs warms my room up something shocking.  I also never turn it off at the plug, just seems pointless plus my PC dislikes it.
Vito_Raliffe on Aug. 25, 2010
Good stuff!
  • Type the words above including the space. Get new words?
Errors will go here
Post Reply
Processing....
Popular News
How To Rip DVDs to Play on Any Device—For Free!

Our ultimate DVD copying guide shows you how to use Handbrake to rip discs for playback on your laptop, Xbox, PS3, iPhone, Zune, netbook, iPad, PSP, iPod, and pretty much anything else

Video: How To Build the Best $1500 Gaming PC, Step-by-Step

Do you like saving money? What about playing PC games? Have you ever considered building your own PC? We show you exactly what you need to know to build an awesome $1500 gaming PC.

How To Build an Awesome $500 Windows Home Server

We pick the best parts to build a lean media backup and streaming machine.

Apple iPad Wi-Fi Review

Apple's device isn't magical, but it is going to make the tablet a real category--for better or for worse

Nexus One vs HTC Desire vs HTC Incredible: What's the Difference?

HTC is releasing more Android phones all the time, but is there a difference?

How To Steal Mac OS's Best Features for Windows

Windows 7's Aero is a fine UI, but there are just a few things it's missing. Here's how to steal some of Mac OS's features.

How To Rip a Blu-Ray Movie with Just One Click

The MakeMKV utility decrypts and rips a Blu-Ray disc with just one click, preserving the original video quality of the source file.

How To Stream All of Your Video Files to iPhone and iPad

Get your DVD rips off your computer and play them on a mobile device, without having to convert them beforehand.

What Kind of Digital Home Upgrades Have You Done?

Ethernet, streaming music, smart power, oh my! What 21st century upgrades have you made to your home?

Why the Obama Administration's Stance on Piracy Sidesteps Complicated Issues

Addressing an audience of workers in the music industry, Commerce Secretary Gary Locke reaffirmed the Obama administration's commitment to cracking down on media piracy on the Internet.

Free Friday - Android Mini-Vinyls! We Love Them So Much!

This week we're giving away an awesome Android Mini figurine. All you need to do to enter is sign up for the site and post a comment in this thread. Yay!

How To Take and Create HDR Photos on Android

Some methods are better than others.

Living with Technology: Two Mice for One Desktop PC

What would drive a man to use two mice for one computer?

Never Give Up: Microsoft May Be Working on One More Zune

Just in time for Apple's new iPod Touch announcement, a rumor is brewing indicating that Microsoft is going to give the Zune another go.

How To Spot Scams and Malware Apps on Android

Some apps are already doing some shady things. Learn how to protect yourself.

Why the All-in-One Multifunction Inkjet Printer is Obsolete

Multifunction printers are big, slow machines that have lots of features, but do none of them well — and they aren't worth your time.

Free Friday - Android Mini-Vinyls! We Love Them So Much!

This week we're giving away an awesome Android Mini figurine. All you need to do to enter is sign up for the site and post a comment in this thread. Yay!

What Kind of Digital Home Upgrades Have You Done?

Ethernet, streaming music, smart power, oh my! What 21st century upgrades have you made to your home?

Never Give Up: Microsoft May Be Working on One More Zune

Just in time for Apple's new iPod Touch announcement, a rumor is brewing indicating that Microsoft is going to give the Zune another go.

Why the Obama Administration's Stance on Piracy Sidesteps Complicated Issues

Addressing an audience of workers in the music industry, Commerce Secretary Gary Locke reaffirmed the Obama administration's commitment to cracking down on media piracy on the Internet.

Living with Technology: Two Mice for One Desktop PC

What would drive a man to use two mice for one computer?

Why the All-in-One Multifunction Inkjet Printer is Obsolete

Multifunction printers are big, slow machines that have lots of features, but do none of them well — and they aren't worth your time.

Why You Should Buy an iPod Classic Before it Goes Away

Last week, Apple revealed it's new line of iPods. Conspicuously absent? The iPod Classic. The high-capacity player is still around, but for how long?

How To Get Great-Sounding Audio for Podcasts and Games

Getting decent audio from your headset or mic isn't hard, and we'll show you a few simple ways to do it.