What are the Best Alternatives to the iPod Shuffle, Nano and Touch?

Topic started by bagels on Sept. 9, 2010. Last post by Wiseblood 1 year, 4 months ago.
Post by bagels (240 posts) See mini bio
Staff
It's hard to escape the news and reviews at this point, so we'll be blunt — Apple has a new line of iPods out, and they're not half bad, either. But they're not for everyone, and as we've discussed before, there are still quite a few users who just aren't fans of the iTunes ecosystem. Some need a device that just plays music — and cheaply at that — which isn't always as easy as it sounds.

So what's a hapless consumer to do? Flash-based iPod alternatives are still alive and well, contrary to what you may think, and we'll show you a few capable models on which to spend your hard earned cash.

The Shuffle

Apple's smallest iPod is pretty sweet. It's damn tiny, and can fit a few thousand songs too. But it isn't your only option. Samsung's YP-S2 pebble is a similar, Shuffle-sized device that works much like Apple's minuscule iPod. There's no screen, and just a standard array of buttons, meaning navigation should be largely familiar.

However, with the lack of a clip or clothing adapter, it may not be the best device for frequent exercise. In that case, the Archos Clipper does much as its name implies. It's nearly twice as big as the latest Shuffle, but still small enough that you probably won't notice. And if you're looking for something really different, Sony has a wearable player that actually sits right on your ear.

Another Nano

The curious thing about the iPod Nano is that you could argue its new redesign is almost too small. While previous models were largely candybar in shape, the latest release looks more like an iPod shuffle in terms of size and dimension — making this the smallest Nano yet. With that in mind, it's very likely you could be yearning for a Nano alternative that's a bit similar to its previous form.

 The iRiver E30. These can be a hard to find in-store, but they can be ordered online. 
The iRiver E30. These can be a hard to find in-store, but they can be ordered online. 
The good thing is that there are numerous non-iPod choices in this space, both with similar storage and battery life configurations. And the physical design isn't half bad either. iRiver has made some great looking devices in previous years that could easily challenge Apple's own. Sony and Creative also have a heavy presence in this space, with models that even play video like the old Nanos too. 

  And if the latest Nano is a little more your style, Archos even has a a small, 1.4" LCD-based player that works in a similar fashion. Sure, there's no multi-touch and iOS style UI, but that's a small price to pay for indulging your iTunes-free lifestyle.

The Touch

Perhaps the most difficult alternative to shop for is Apple's most popular iPod, the Touch. In fact, what makes this device so problematic is just how unlike an iPod it actually is. Considering it shares the same iOS ecosystem as the iPhone, there's really no other device that comes anywhere close in terms of apps, gaming or internet capabilities. But that's not to say other companies wont try.

 Microsoft's Zune HD.
Microsoft's Zune HD.
Perhaps the most similar alternative is Microsoft's own Zune HD. It's one of the better iPod alternatives on the market, and competes with similar features as wireless connectivity, a 3.3" touchscreen and a modest collection of apps and games. It's about the farthest you can get from the iTunes ecosystem, and you even have access to Zune Pass, if that's your thing.

If you're hoping to replicate the Touch's newly-minted video capture capabilities, you're in luck. Archos' line of Android-based multimedia players can actually shoot 720p quality video, along with access to the Android market in a similar manner to Apple's ecosystem. You can't get much worse than Android's stock player, so we assume the Archos skin is something of an improvement.

What we're most curious to hear, however, is what sort of iPod-alternatives you use. Are today's flash-based offerings enough enticement away from the Apple ecosystem? Let us know in the comments!      
 
Images via Flickr users nino63004, 朝歌@Taurus and robertnelson.
Post by JesseCherry (34 posts) See mini bio
Nice to see some alternatives for the shuffle because I'm sick of my sweat breaking shuffles. I also hate paying way to much for crappy headphones that are the only way to control the current one I have.
Post by makc@bezeqint.net (24 posts) See mini bio
No mention of Archos devices? Tsk Tsk Tsk...
They have some great, quality stuff for affordable prices. My Archos Gmini 400 that I've had since 2004 is still the best sounding portable player I've ever had.
Post by alternate (78 posts) See mini bio
I went for a Sandisk Sansa clip+ over the shuffle.  It it much cheaper and actually has a clip - which the shuffle didn't have at the time.  Good features, a readable little screen, 2-8gb base extendible with micro SD, good sound output for size.  The only disadvantage is the earbuds are trash so factor in another £10 ($7) for some good ones.
Post by ReDead_Zora (16 posts) See mini bio
@max3000: He actually referenced an Archos product as an alternative for every iPod. 
For the shuffle he recommended the Archos Clipper; For the Nano, the Archos 14 Vision & for the touch, the Archos 32 tablet. 
Post by Zeninnnnnnnn (19 posts) See mini bio
I use a Zune HD. While it may have around ten apps I find it to be a FAR better music player. The menus are very easy on the eyes and provide a far greater organization system than the iPod touch.
Post by billykop1 (4 posts) See mini bio
this is great but do you have any recommendations on which ones are the best?  specifically in the nano-sized players?
Post by Rolento (47 posts) See mini bio
Love my Zune HD.  Wouldn't trade it for anything else.
Post by Jasonofindy (8 posts) See mini bio
I'm currently using a 16 GB Sony Walkman and really like it.  I mainly use it for listening to podcasts or the radio when I'm mowing, but it also holds some of my favorite music playlists and has replaced the "family photo" section of my wallet.  It technically also supports video playback, but I've never used that functionality as I have no need or desire to watch video on a 2 inch screen.
Post by nukesniper (32 posts) See mini bio
The Zune HD is an awesome choice in my opinion. I have an iPhone 3G and an old Zune (launch day and it still works almost four years later) and I HATE to hook my iPhone to my computer because it is a hassle to do anything with it while hooked to iTunes. I haven't even put it on iOS 4 yet because it wants to wipe everything off my iPhone, and, since my computer it is connected to has passed on, it wants to wipe everything off my iPhone to do it without backing it up. I want to keep my stuff how it is thank you. 
 
The Zune is super easy. I can hook my Zune to my computer and put my four podcasts per week or whatever on it, and it only takes me about a minute to do so. When, at best, it took my iPhone a period of "I'll just leave it overnight and see if it is done in the morning" to do something so simple. 
 
The Zune is a product that I think the world would like a lot if they got to try it. I come from a history of Apple devices dying a month or two after I could get it replaced and I love the Zune because I haven't had it break yet. I'll stick with Zune as long as I can, and I'm running to Android this month when my iPhone contract is up. 
Post by Outrager (57 posts) See mini bio
That ARCHOS 32 looks pretty cool. The price is nice, but it kind of sucks that they don't have more storage or an SD slot.
Post by Shadowsquire (35 posts) See mini bio
@max3000 said:
"No mention of Archos devices? Tsk Tsk Tsk... They have some great, quality stuff for affordable prices. My Archos Gmini 400 that I've had since 2004 is still the best sounding portable player I've ever had. "

Umm... he did mention Archos. 3 times in fact. 
Btw, Zune HD FTW!
Post by grbear (48 posts) See mini bio

I have to agree with alternate. I have an original Sansa clip and I'd recomend it over the shuffle everytime.
Post by TheMasterDS (134 posts) See mini bio
Yeah I'd recommend a nice Zune HD, or perhaps wait and see if there's an HD 2 coming this year since the first won't be the iPod Touch to Windows Phone 7's iPhone, though I think the apps are hardly worth mentioning. Zune HD's appeal lies solely in its phenomenal UI.
Post by Kyodra (16 posts) See mini bio
Sansa Clip+ is actually far better than iPod Shuffle, having a screen makes it easier to navigate, excellent for podcasts, expandable memory with Micro SD and no iTunes needed.
Post by OneManX (17 posts) See mini bio
@Kyodra said:
" Sansa Clip+ is actually far better than iPod Shuffle, having a screen makes it easier to navigate, excellent for podcasts, expandable memory with Micro SD and no iTunes needed. "
Honestly I couldn't agree more, I'vehad a Sansa Clip for awhile and used it constantly, for working out, or just to wear while I worked, and the screen and slightly lower price point makes it a good alternative for the Shuffle.
Post by Hosstile17 (1 posts) See mini bio
I bought a Zune 30 Gig back in 07. Dude, it is brown. If they made a brown iPod, I would totally buy one.
Post by MichaelBach (94 posts) See mini bio
Wasn't there supposed to come out an iPad / iPod-Touch hybrid??
Post by Portis (138 posts) See mini bio
I also use a Zune HD, my last media player before that being a iPod Touch. I was extremely excited about it and bought it day one. So far its exceeded (most) of my expectations.
 
It has its problems, but I would not trade it for the world. Out of its many neat little features, there is one thing I really, really enjoy above all else -- streaming music from the marketplace with the device. I use that quite a bit. Its biggest downfall is easily the app situation. The fact that they have trickled down into the marketplace at such a snails pace was something I was not expecting. I mean, I was sure they'd be slow with the releases, but not this slow. However the apps they do release are usually of a high quality (and free), I'll give them that.
 
As someone else point out -- if the public at large would've given the Zune HD a try, I'm sure alot of people would've liked it. I do think (most) of the iPod line are great, sexy looking products, but the stranglehold that Apple has on the MP3 market worries me.
Post by KnifeySpoony (4 posts) See mini bio
What about alternatives for mass storage devices that can be alternatives to the iPod classic?
 
I don't care about touchscreens or other stuff, I just want the size to handle everything I throw at it.